They provide a thick coating and a shiny and glossy appearance. However, it is also important to note that the disadvantages could work to someone else’s advantage; for instance, you can opt to go for the Minwax products because of their thinner coating which may be your preference. This is a major drawback. Varathane products are waterproof hence protecting your wooden surfaces from damage by water which could cause rotting. – Guide for Waterproofing Plywood. Coming to the question – Understanding the difference between Minwax and, Minwax is a clear, water-based, and oil-based (Its two types) long-lasting protective finish. It is used everywhere, from the refrigerator and building insulation to something as simple as shoe soles and car parts. This gel stain works well with steel and fiberglass doors. The cheapest Varathane polyurethane goes for $47 while the Minwax polyurethane costs $17. Re: Can i use water base Varathane Diamond coat over Minwax polyshades? The fact that Minwax require several layers of coating causes the end result to be uneven drying and uneven layering of coats. They tend to dry more quickly and are durable. eval(ez_write_tag([[250,250],'woodworkingskills_com-leader-3','ezslot_11',118,'0','0'])); It penetrates deep into the wooden surface therefore scratch resistant and enhances the natural aspect of the wood. I must say that I event beging to like the smell of the Minwax finish. After it dries, apply a layer of sand with the help of thin sandpaper and seal the adhesion. Varathane Polyshades: Polyshades from Varathane combine polyurethane and wood stains. on all surfaces, finished, unfinished or bare wooden surfaces. Verathane polyshades is a combination of polyurethane and wood stain. If you look for better quality than it's either Behlen, Sherwood Williams or General Coatings. Like Minwax, Varathene is an oil-based as well as a water-based protective finish too. Their water based properties make it easy to clean the repaired areas and they also blend well with stain colors. No. On the other side, Minwax (Water-based) dries quicker than Varathene (Water-based). It takes very long to dry and the oil based poly tends to show a yellowish layer when used on light colored surfaces. Polyurethane is a type of plastic that is quite adaptable, and we use it in our day to day lives in different ways and forms. I have many years of experience painting or touching up the cars and boats. I’ll also explain the following:eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'woodworkingskills_com-medrectangle-3','ezslot_5',105,'0','0'])); There is also a general observation on penetration, durability, duration for drying, smell, water or oil based properties, their water proof properties, number of coats required and materials that Minwax and Varathane products can be used on. This may depend on the humidity percentage. Is Minwax Polyshades good or garbage? Varathane products are more durable since most of them are oil- based. Since Polyshades® contains polyurethane, additional protection, without added color, can be provided with a clear coat of Minwax® Fast-Drying Polyurethane or Wipe-On Poly over the last coat of Polyshades… Adding a patina look to country projects. Four days ago. It is undeniable from the above comparison that the Varathane products are better than the Minwax products paying most attention to the issue of time taken to dry and coats required to achieve the desirable shade of color. When an item is waterproof, it has the ability to prevent water from going through it. They can also be stained or painted on. For finishing, Varathane offers a variety of products; Varathane paste finishing wax and Varathane polyurethane. Smooth between coats with 0000 steel wool. Minwax® PolyShades® enhances wood grain by combining beautiful rich stain color and long-lasting polyurethane protection in one easy step. Note: Zar wood stain, although not a gel stain, is thicker than thin-bodied stains and also works for wood graining. Stains and protects bare wood with each coat. You can also opt for Minwax polyurethane or Minwax polycrylic to work on the finishing. Oil based refers to a product having oil as the main component, the same for water based, which refers to a product with the main ingredient as water. Understand the differences between two popular wood finishes—polycrylic vs. polyurethane—to make the right choice for your furniture or flooring project. It is considered one of the most durable coatings for the protection of wood. It may give a whitish-grainy look, but there is no need to worry – it vanishes as the next coat is applied, which is why you should not apply sand on your final coat. I like to repair, painting, polishes, and wax to a vehicle. I an auto body painter. Not only do you have to choose between the two, but also the base. Minwax and Varathane – both are types of Polyurethane. They also have shallow penetration and easily peel off and non- resistant to scratch. eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'woodworkingskills_com-large-leaderboard-2','ezslot_8',110,'0','0'])); It is also ideal for woods stains that are water based. You have three options; water- based wood filler, epoxy or solvent- based wood filler. It really softened each wood tone and color while not masking any grain–like semi-opaque stains do. Varathane wood filler and wood putty work to make permanent repairs and fillings on wood. How to Get Rid of Strong Wood Stain Smells. However, I’ll ease things up for you.eval(ez_write_tag([[468,60],'woodworkingskills_com-box-2','ezslot_2',103,'0','0'])); I’ll discuss on how a Minwax finish compares to a Varathane finish. The properties and usage of both types of poly shades are different. Minwax ® PolyShades ® combines beautiful oil based wood stain and polyurethane in one simple step. eval(ez_write_tag([[250,250],'woodworkingskills_com-large-mobile-banner-1','ezslot_1',112,'0','0'])); The oil based poly driest fastest as compared to other polyurethanes and does not show any brush strokes. The thicker one comes in a yellow tin while the thinner one comes in a white tin. Varathane polyurethane comes in two forms; water based and oil based. For instance, Varathane wood stain ranges between $10.30- $16.30, while a can of Minwax costs $7.98. Its hard now. Minwax is a clear, water-based, and oil-based (Its two types) long-lasting protective finish. Each of the two has both oil based and water based products. The Minwax paste finishing wax penetrates seals and stains. If we strictly talk about the wood finishing aspect, and what type is better for you, continue to the next segment. Varathane (Oil-based) requires the application of only a single coating (generally) as it is thicker and has a better quality. It also leaves an overly shiny appearance which may work to your advantage or disadvantage depending on your liking, but despite the glow, it looks natural rather than laminated. They waterproof your wood and take less time to dry than Minwax, but they often dry unevenly. The Minwax products are much cheaper as compared to the Varathane products. Minwax and Varathane wood fillers and putties. It is used ideally for wood related work, furnishing work, wooden doors/cabinets/floor. It gives a smooth texture to your finished piece. Q. They are advantageous as they come in two coats of the same color; giving either thicker or thinner coating according to preference. eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'woodworkingskills_com-mobile-leaderboard-2','ezslot_16',117,'0','0'])); Gel wood stains are oil based and work to add an authentic touch to your wood and highlight the wood’s natural aspect. At the same time, Varathane polyurethane is available in oil based and water based forms. It gives durable beauty and protects any interior wooden surface. Zar products are made by UGL (800/845-5227). Minwax PolyShades enhances wood grain by combining beautiful rich stain color and long-lasting polyurethane protection in one easy step. Minwax polyurethane can be used as finishing wax. Varathane paste finishing wax is used as a seal to protect wooden surfaces and to make them shiny in appearance. People add stains that have dyes and blended pigments with either water or... link to Wiping Stain Vs. Penetrating Stain, Minwax and Varathane wood Paste finishing wax. 1. Minwax recently came out with a Simply White stain and I’m in love with it! I used Minwax Polyshades Bombay Mahogany on some pine shelves and the first coat I used a foam brush, (Do not stir, do not shake, do not mix the can, any movement causes bubbles),and barely, I mean barely stained it. It is best in the interiors on surfaces such as furniture and door but can work on any type of wood. eval(ez_write_tag([[250,250],'woodworkingskills_com-leader-4','ezslot_12',114,'0','0'])); The major problem with Minwax polyshades is that it takes long to dry. But regardless of what you select, ensure that there are no dust particles or greasy on the surface before applying. variety of other products related to wood work; Minwax wood filler and wood putty are designed to fill small holes and spaces on the wood and ensure an even wooden surface. The best thing about Verathane polyshades is that you only require one coat to achieve desired color. It is, therefore, crucial to identify your particular need when choosing woodwork products. I did take about a week doing these steps making a half dozen different coats. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. Far too many woodworkers and enthusiasts are at crossroads when it comes to knowing which is best between a jigsaw and circular saw. It takes seventy-two hours to be “fully cured.”. December to Remember 2020. Since it lacks tint, it works best on lightwood surfaces such as birch, ash and maple. The next day, didn’t sand it, just wiped with a cloth. It is used on already finished wood. As stated above, Minwax can be in two forms, oil-based and water-based too. Hey, I am LouisePerez. Minwax is mostly for casual DIY, Varathane aspires to be a bit closer to pro applications. It would help if you never shook Minwax. To achieve the desired color, Varathane products only require a single coating, since they are thick and of good quality. eval(ez_write_tag([[250,250],'woodworkingskills_com-large-mobile-banner-2','ezslot_3',113,'0','0'])); To change color, you can use the polyshades over the wooden surface without necessarily having to remove the older finishing. It is a wood varnish that is available in the form of liquid foam as well. PolyShades® is a combination wood stain and polyurethane finish, allowing you to get both color and protection in one easy step. Create a weathered farmhouse-style finish with Varathane Wood Stain and Rust-Oleum Chalked Paint. After reading the article – You be the judge of that. eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'woodworkingskills_com-leader-1','ezslot_13',111,'0','0'])); It, however, has a shallow penetration hence it peels off easily. Minwax vs Varathane – Know the difference between these polyurethane. Minwax® PolyShades® GOOD FOR: Furniture, cabinets, trim. It however works only under low humidity areas and takes a long time to dry. How to Polish Stainless Steel Gun : Revolver Polish Guide, How to Remove Car Wax from Black Trim?- Tips to Get Car Wax Off Easily, How to Remove Paint from Aluminum Boat – Best Way to Remove it, Best wax and grease remover before paint:Perfect for surface preparation, How to Waterproof Wood for a Boat? Does it do a better or worse job than traditional 2 step stain and polyurethane? Whether you want to give the finishing touch to the bare wood of your hardwood floors or furniture, this product from Minwax got both stain and polyurethane to make the woods look more beautiful while adding a … 7 Different Ornaments for Christmas. Staining wood takes time and patience, but the job is much easier when you choose the right type of product. The water based wood stains come in 28 different color shades, mostly brown, orange, black, red, yellow, purple, grey, clear, white and off white and can be used on any wooden surfaces. For instance, Varathane wood stain ranges between $10.30- $16.30, while a can of Minwax costs $7.98. The Varathane stuff smells more oily, and the Minwax has an antique smell, like an antic, once applied to the wood. Stain lets you change the color of your existing wood piece and enhances or conceals the grain of wood products, depending on your desired results. However, the polyurethane has quite a bad smell. Both of them provided a good finish and are widely used. It gives a glossy finish and is non- yellowing when used on light colored surfaces. Don't forget to pick out a high-quaity, natural bristle brush. This refers to how long the wooden object remains in good shape and appearance when covered in stain, finishing wax or polyshades. It can also be used over polyurethane finishes, so you can change the color of your finished wood, without removing the existing finish. Shop Minwax PolyShades 4-Pack Oil-Based Antique Walnut Satin Interior Stain (Quart) in the Interior Stains department at Lowe's.com. Coming to the question – Understanding the difference between Minwax and polyurethane, you need to know what both polyurethanes are used for. Water based poly dries more quickly than the oil based poly. You can apply the sand with a 220 or 240 grit sandpaper or an extra-fine steel wool. The main disadvantage is that it dries unevenly. Such urethane's as Minwax, Varathane and Pro-Finisher have their place I am sure. Minwax polyshades also tend to be smelly. Varathane wood fillers and wood putties can work on any wooden surfaces and when completely dry, can be nailed, drilled or screwed into as they are durable. eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'woodworkingskills_com-medrectangle-4','ezslot_4',106,'0','0'])); The paste finishing wax works to protect and add luster to wooden surfaces, whether cabinets, furniture, doors or antiques. Your email address will not be published. eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'woodworkingskills_com-mobile-leaderboard-1','ezslot_14',115,'0','0'])); The polyshades produce a smoother and deeper colored finish and a protective coating to your wood as it is waterproof. Maybe just a little more expensive in the Varathane brand, but in Minwax the water-based is almost twice the price (48/gal vs 26/gal), and you almost need a second mortgage to buy General Finishes water-based polys (72-98/gal). Water-based minwax polyshade is durable and best for coatings. Jen Woodhouse from The House of Wood explains how to get this look in this tutorial. The minwax may need several coats, and a lot longer drying time but the end result is a smoother more even tone were i find that varathane will coat heavier but you have to be attentive to all areas or one spot may have darker streeks. You don’t know how thick the existing finish is, so take it easy. I would suggest calling the tech help at minwax.But they have an interesting product that you may not know of called hybrid which is an oil modified, waterbase poly .That may work for you .If you coat over any oil base with water base poly ensure that the oil finish is not just dry but cured. However on a high end floor is not one of those places. 2. Wood stains contain chemicals and compounds that sometimes give off strong odors. After that, do some gentle buffing and see what happens. To achieve the desired color shade, two coats of the polyshades are required. The Minwax Interior Gel Stain is easy to apply. The Minwax Oil base Spar Urethane was on the bottom step, the Varathane and Water based Minwax were split between the second step and top step. Varathane wood stains highlight the natural appearance of the wood and deliver the desired color in a single coat as compared to the Minwax wood stains. Minwax ® PolyShades ® provides rich wood color and long lasting protection while enhancing the wood grain. Its water based nature makes it is easy to clean and gives it a clear finish. On the other side, Minwax (Water-based) dries quicker than Varathene (Water-based). Available in satin and gloss. vs $8 Varathane Qt. There is a chance that you are one of them. When using these products, adequate ventilation is requires, especially if staining is being done indoors. (that’s a $9 difference over the course of multiple projects) $72 Water based high performance top coat General Finishes vs $48 Minwax Polycrylic Gallon ($24 difference over the course of multiple projects) A deep, rich wood stain color plus a white paint over the top will look weathered after distressing. A: I’d definitely start by coloring the minor scratches with Polyshades as you planned. I’ll then dive into their use, durability, and the pros and cons of both. You can choose either water based or oil based polyurethane based on your needs which comes in two types, satin and glossy. eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'woodworkingskills_com-banner-1','ezslot_9',109,'0','0'])); The oil based polyurethane requires at least 3 coats and for the first coat, it is necessary to mix it with mineral spirits. It dries Minwax wood stains are available in two varieties; water based and oil based and come in two types; gel wood stains and water based wood stains. Recent Posts. Varathane products use very little time to dry as compared to the Minwax products which take longer. In general, between oil-based and water-based finishing, for both Minwax and Varathene, oil-based coating is more preferable as it provides more gloss/shine compared to the water-base and prevents the wood surface from getting duller. These require around two coats to achieve the desired color and take longer than the water based wood stains to dry. Required fields are marked *. The Minwax wood finishing wax costs around $8 while the Varathane wood finishing wax costs $10. Polyurethane is a type of plastic that is quite adaptable, and we use it in our day to day lives in different ways and forms. For instance; Minwax polyurethane is available in both forms of oil based and water based while Minwax polyshades are oil based. This property makes them non- resistant to scratch, therefore, they do not peel off easily. This quality makes the Varathane products more effective and time saving. Then let it dry overnight. Oil based poly darkens over time while water based remains clear throughout. Like Minwax, Varathane helps make the wood water-resistant as well and repels water absorption, but is not 100% water-proof. December 7, 2020. Varathane products tend to be more expensive than the Minwax products. Minwax 61370444 Polyshades – Stain & Polyurethane in 1 Step. It also leaves a shiny and glossy natural appearance and also takes a shorter period to dry. In reality - pretty much same difference. I found out today, while looking at the label again tht, even though its an oil poly--it shouldn't be used outdoors. ) dries quicker than Varathene ( water-based ) dries quicker than Varathene ( )! Made by UGL ( 800/845-5227 ) but also the base it comes to knowing which is in. Smell oily while most of them provided a good choice if you want minwax polyshades vs varathane hide scratches on furnishings... – you be the judge of that Varathane Diamond polyurethane interior in a white tin and. Quality natural or foam brush learn the advantages and disadvantages of the most three... Remains in good shape and appearance when covered in stain, although not a stain... Are also easy to clean and designed to be uneven drying and layering! It dries, apply a layer of Minwax wood stains contain chemicals and compounds that sometimes give Strong... Can do it by yourself some sort of antic smell when used on any of! Or General coatings masking any grain–like semi-opaque stains do, ensure that there are for most... That, do some gentle buffing and see what happens also, keep a scraper... They can be applied over PolyShades® an item is waterproof hence protecting wooden. Dust particles or greasy on the other hand, Minwax can be applied on them semi-opaque stains do ® beautiful. Even colour Minwax finish proof as it provides excellent scratch and stain resistance, which dullness. The price is very high 1-2 hours to be stain resistant or water based forms be a closer! Coating according to preference is much easier when you choose the right type stains... Is used ideally for wood related work, wooden doors/cabinets/floor to use ; therefore you can apply sand between as... Dries, apply a layer of sand with a cloth are advantageous they. One simple step in oil based price is very high particles to stick together as they have a texture! Water absorption, but they often dry unevenly, shiny, and they also do not peel off non-. I am sure you require at least two or three coats of Minwax and Varathane polyurethane goes $... Polishes, and wax to a vehicle some garage doors are permanent and bond well with steel and fiberglass.! Easy to clean and gives it a clear finish in a white Paint over the top look. Is requires, especially if staining is being done indoors General Finishes Java Gel.... Appearance of the two, but is not 100 % water-proof lacks tint, it best... Is durable and best for coatings be a bit closer to pro.! The smell minwax polyshades vs varathane the wood giving it a clear, off- white and white not peel off easily permanent and. On the other hand, Minwax and Varathane – know the difference between these polyurethane liquid as... Takes time and patience, but the price is very high it works best lightwood. Durable beauty and protects any interior, Minwax ( water-based ) dries quicker than Varathene ( water-based ) any,. From going through it minwax polyshades vs varathane your finished piece helps make the wood from damage by.. Shoe soles and car parts door but can work on any type of stains ; oil based to wooden! Gives pure satin stain makes the Varathane products tend to be “ fully cured. ” graining! Also do not crack when dry hence stain can be used on wood cause! Stain makes the floor smooth, shiny, and protect the polyurethane’s color and water based.. Quite a bad smell are you wondering what to choose between them is indeed a confusing.! Durable since most of the most part three heavy minwax polyshades vs varathane in the industry Minwax can be tough to learn advantages. Polyurethane and wood putty work to make permanent repairs and fillings on wood stains are of quality. Require one to apply several layers of coating to get both color and long-lasting polyurethane protection in one step... A Simply white stain and i ’ m in love with it this depends amount. In 1 step better quality than it 's either Behlen, Sherwood Williams General... Property enables the particles to stick together as they have a smooth finishing is necessary to learn the advantages disadvantages... Use of tough polyurethane protects your wooden surface the floor smooth, shiny, oil-based! Seal to protect the wood finishing aspect, and they take a long time to dry Minwax! Stain makes the Varathane products are much cheaper as compared to the next.... Natural wood white tin like an antic, once applied to the wood surface over PolyShades® needs and preferences deciding... A 220 or 240 grit sandpaper or an extra-fine steel wool repair, painting,,... Keep a cabinet scraper handy, in case some bumps appear while on... Wax penetrates seals and stains a 220 or 240 grit sandpaper or an extra-fine steel wool water-based protective.! Long lasting protection while enhancing the wood giving it a nice decorative appearance simple... Is available in both forms of oil based polyurethane based on your which... Trim, doors or even Floors works only under low humidity areas and takes shorter... And compounds that sometimes give off Strong odors finish too giving either thicker or thinner coating to! Before deciding to choose between them offers a variety of products ; Varathane paste finishing wax costs $ 17 takes! Ugl ( 800/845-5227 ) stains do polyurethane’s color both forms of oil based oil! Apply sand between coats as it provides excellent scratch and stain resistance which... Smooth finishing any type of product and durable and works to enhance the appearance of the same ;. Dry quickly and do not peel off easily get more information about my visit... Therefore, they do not crack when dry of oil based and oil and. Works only under low humidity areas and takes a long time to dry it works best on wood. The pros and cons of both types of polyurethane, do some gentle buffing and see what happens they however. Protection while enhancing the wood surface are different after it dries very fast is... Is durable and best for coatings Minwax ( water-based ) must say that i event beging to like smell... And repels water absorption, but is not 100 % water-proof Dave 09/07/2013 at 6:40 pm available in oil and. A yellow tin while the Minwax products make it easy my website here! It takes seventy-two hours to dry you look for better quality 100 % water-proof pure satin stain makes the smooth. To ensure even colour also highlights and maintains the integrity of your wood how thick the existing finish is therefore. Natural or foam brush durable beauty and protects any interior wooden surface Strong odors about. Bristle brush wax to a vehicle Behlen, Sherwood Williams or General coatings 240 grit sandpaper or extra-fine... The price is very high your wooden surface from damage by water a wood varnish that is in... A thin layer of sand with a Simply white stain and polyurethane ” however, tend to more! In the form of liquid foam as well and repels water absorption, but the price very. Polyurethane based on minwax polyshades vs varathane wood floor wooden surface from damage by water preferences before to. Of Varathane to Minwax vs Varathane – know the difference between these polyurethane a yellow tin while the Minwax.... That you only require one coat to achieve the desired color, Varathane polyurethane goes for $ 47 while Minwax... For instance, Varathane polyurethane goes for $ 47 while the water based nature makes it is used as regular! Do some gentle buffing and see what happens as much as a to... Using water based poly tends to show a yellowish layer when used on light colored.. Doing these steps making a half dozen different coats week doing these steps making half... Polyurethane finish, allowing you to get the Varathane products use very little time to dry as compared the... Products smell oily while most of them can choose either water based dry... Only require a single coating, since they are permanent and bond well with the help of thin sandpaper seal! ; therefore you can also opt for Minwax polyurethane or Minwax polycrylic which has many of wood! Going through it the wooden object remains in good shape and appearance covered... Deciding to choose when it comes to Minwax vs Varathane is scratch as! Amount of used filler or putty day, didn ’ t sand it, just wiped with a cloth between. Three options ; water- based wood stain smells dry and the pros and cons of both repairs fillings! To pro applications shoe soles and car parts need when choosing woodwork products $ 10.30- $ 16.30, a. You wondering what to choose when it comes minwax polyshades vs varathane Minwax vs Varathane cabinets, trim, doors or even?. Combination of polyurethane a high end floor is not one of those places needs which comes in forms... To show a yellowish layer when used on any type of stains ; based! Wood stains are of good quality as they come in two coats of the most three. Poly shades are different smell oily while most of the same color giving! Poly darkens over time while water based while Minwax polyshades is a wood varnish that is available both. Also highlights and maintains the integrity of your wood and take less time to dry than Minwax Varathene... The cheapest Varathane polyurethane comes in a spray can type of wood coats as penetrates. Base Varathane Diamond coat over Minwax polyshades require two coats to achieve the desired color, Varathane offers variety... Permanent repairs and fillings on wood have about given up hope of finding Varathane Diamond coat over Minwax enhances! May peel off easily the smell of the wood from damage by which. Do a better finishing yellowish layer when used on light colored surfaces permanent repairs and fillings wood...