The story was so that it kept my interest as I kept wondering where it was going to go with all this and I felt at one point it would turn out a bit clich. The movie also has an acceptable look and good period detail. Director Brad Anderson Writers Edgar Allan Poe Joe Gangemi Stars Kate Beckinsale Jim Sturgess David Thewlis I only watched this movie because it had the word "Asylum" in the title (Honestly - I just hoped it would have some Arkham Asylum type crazies in it). When you've made an absolute masterpiece like 'SESSION 9' (and not everyone necessarily agrees) it is a pretty difficult thing to follow. But before Newgate can take a sip, Graves makes him spill the drink. Newgate also seems interested in comely patient Eliza Graves (Kate Beckinsale). The film Stonehearst Asylum, set in England at the turn of the 20th century, hopes to explore these same sort of issues but with less success. One of acceptance and comfort. The distinction is clear: Stonehearst is a piece of property, Lambs kingdom. Took me for a loop! for disturbing and violent images, sexual content and language, 10th Chicago Critics Film Fest Features Past Lives, Blackberry, Sanctuary, Theater Camp, and Many More, A Road Paved with Bloodshed: High Plains Drifter Turns 50, Cannes 2023 Line-up Includes Wes Anderson, Martin Scorsese, and Many More, Ebertfest Welcomes Molly Cornyn as its New Project Coordinator. Some are simply not mad enough to admit it. This film seemingly passed me by, so I was so glad to accidentally stumble across it, I'll say categorically that this is a superb movie. It is where the privileged few go when their minds break. Here are 22 essential L.A. spots for every tourist, Column: We cant afford another writers strike. Staff members Paxton and Swanwick escape but are hunted down and slain by several inmates led by Finn. Stonehearst Asylum um filme de suspense norte-americano de 2014, dirigido por Brad Anderson. from asylum asylum by madeleine roux. Newgate observes the patients and the treatment for a while. It felt a bit too over the top and melodramatic to actually be funny. I guess IMDb authorities have to find ways to prevent organised efforts leading to high/low rating of the movies in their website. Fraternization between loonies and staffers is not at all discouraged; in fact, one might in have a very hard time distinguishing between them. External Reviews They didn't have ways to keep track of people. Though the patient protests that she is sane, the professor points out that all mental patients claim to be sane. Despite reservations, Newgate gamely considers Lambs revolutionary treatment ideas which basically eliminate treatment. Awards Directed by Brad Anderson from a script by Joe Gangemi based on the 1844 story "The System of Doctor Tarr and Professor Feather " by Edgar Allan Poe, STONEHEARST ASYLUM abounds with twists and turns set against a richly textured and lush, stylized Victorian-era vi. Comparison Between Stonehearst Asylum and The System of Dr. Tarr and Prof. Fether Changed Time, Switched Space In terms of timing, The System of Dr. Tarr and Prof. Fether takes place in the autumn of the 19th century, a very common day in the long history. A group of armed men led by Mickey Finn allow him entry. Poes The System of Dr. Tarr and Prof. Fether provided the main fodder for Joseph Gangemis screenplay, which succeeds in devising a series of intriguing plot turns. Eliza, recognizing that Newgate is a compassionate man, begs him to flee Stonehearst but he refuses to leave without her. Brad Anderson is one of our most underrated filmmakers, a film about insanity and abuse of power, its surprisingly tame. With Stonehearst Asylum, director Brad Anderson doles out a vintage Halloween treat a straightforward Poe adaptation of the sort that Vincent Price used to star in and gives it a freshness and complexity that make it a delight. Offered a tour of the grounds, he soon learns the truth about the new methodology put in place since the system of soothing was abandoned. The written works of Edgar Allan Poe have made for some fine movie adaptations over the years, like the ones Roger Corman made during the 1960s. As a retired therapist and psychology teacher, I love films that talk about the history of mental health treatment--and this film is set during the bad old days of mental health treatment, when asylums were practically houses of horror. An Oxford graduate takes up a job in a mental asylum, only to discover that the "revolutionary" new treatments are inhumane, and that there is more going on than meets the eye. But for me the ending seems to be way over done particularly when compared to the story's starting point. [13], On November 25, 2013, John Debney was set to score the music for the film. HarperPerennial Classics brings great works of literature to life in digital format, upholding the highest standards in ebook production and celebrating reading in all its forms. I did not see that ending coming. Club both praised the film for its themes;[21] the reviewer for Film Journal International wrote, "While the film lacks the macabre humor of the original story, it does an excellent job of conveying the creeping horror of Victorian medicine. He does successfully pretend to be a doctor, he witnesses some legitimate (for the time) electrical therapy, an accident causes a fire (possibly due to a boiler fault, which was established) and he absconds with the girl. He was dancing with his love interest at another Asylum and they call each other Mr. and Mrs. Lamb. They may be continuing his fantasy together running the asylum, or just picked a nice place to be crazy together. Stonehearst Asylum review - supremely entertaining Poe-inspired gothic thriller. Its an amazing story that shows Poes genius! Overall, a movie that is good and worth seeing but with this cast I feel it could have been better. Create New A 2014 film starring Jim Sturgess, Kate Beckinsale, Ben Kingsley and Michael Caine, based on the short story The System of Doctor Tarr and Professor Fether by Edgar Allan Poe. My Secret Valentine Movie Filming Locations Revealed. The captive staff tells Newgate that Lamb and Finn led the revolt. Lamb refers to his Stonehearst as a grand experiment, one where both the roles and the conception of sane and insane are flipped. | Poor Edgar Allan Poe. The movie is loosely based on the short story "The System of Doctor Tarr and Professor Fether" by Edgar. The patient who thinks hes a horse is left to do horsy things. A young woman named Eliza Graves (Kate Beckinsale) is being paraded in front of a room of mental health experts.The doctor in charge (Brendan Gleeson) claims that she is mentally ill, however Anderson films the scene in a way that makes the men in the room menacing, teasing a film that should follow . My eyes were glued to the screen. (LogOut/ The author affords is a strange tale of an asylum with a liberal methodology and the consequences thereof. A recent medical school grad who takes a position at a mental institution soon finds himself taken with one of his colleagues -- though he has no initial idea of a recent, horrifying staffing change. I loved "Stonehearst Asylum" and consider it among the best films I've seen recently. I found this movie on Netflix streaming movies. Add to this that the film is based loosely (very loosely) on an Edgar Allen Poe story and you've got most of what you'd need to capture my interest. Welcome to /r/FanTheories! Excellent short story worth reading, especially after watching Stonehearst Asylum. But the scare, that terror of being locked away and at the mercy of the barbaric remedies used at the time to treat mental ails, never takes hold. Madness and mayhem are the watchwords of the day when it comes to STONEHEARST ASYLUM. A couple of days before 1899 Christmas, the Oxford new graduate Dr. Edward Newgate arrives at the Stonehearst Asylum to complete training for his specialty of asylum medicine. The ending of Stonehearst Asylum sees Newgate asking Graves to run away with him. tricks of the trade with the dread required for this story to work. Stonehearst Asylum is worth watching for many things. I definitely love Poes stories that come with a twist! It's loosely based on an Edgar Allan Poe short story. [17], Common criticism for the film centered upon what the reviewers felt was the film's failure to live up to its full potential, considering its atmosphere and all-A-list cast. The movie left a lot to be lacking but the story had an amazing twist that I thought would be utterly shocking at the time of writing. Stonehearst Asylum: Short Story Edgar Allan Poe 3.81 1,224 ratings126 reviews When a young man visits a French mental institution to learn about the hospital's "system of soothing," he is surprised to learn that it has recently abandoned the treatment method. The man that the staff thought to be Newgate, was an escaped mental patient with Pseudologia Fantastica. The old nurse is now the head of the asylum, when she was rotting in a cell barely fed for months just a 3 weeks prior. Lamb says that he does not believe in drugging or incarcerating patients, and he encourages their delusions when he feels it will bring them greater happiness. But the fear factor eludes him, leaving Stonehearst Asylum more insipid than insane. But Salt has been replaced by Dr. Silas Lamb (Kingsley), who agrees to take on Newgate as his assistant. A predictable story of the inner workings of an insane asylum. "[16] On Metacritic, the film has a weighted average score of 52 out of 100, based on 14 critics, indicating "mixed or average reviews". The acting overall is a nice job for me. of Horror titled Sounds Like, one of the best in the short-lived Showtime for the director amplifies my frustration with his latest. Release: 2014-10-24. Entertainment Reviews from a Wee Scottish Wife and Stepmum living in Finland. It soon becomes apparent that the real director of the asylum, Dr Salt (Michael Caine), has been deposed by one of his patients and is kept locked up in the basement with the rest of his staff. The setting is a British insane asylum whose troubled patients on a snowy Christmas Eve in 1899 occupy a once-mannerly estate that has slipped into very ill-mannered debauchery and decay. I liked the idea of this and the twists were perfect and placed at the right time. Convinced that something must be done, Newgate attempts to spike the champagne. However, I'll be honest with you--why I like it probably isn't the reason you'd like the film. Jonathan Majors Dropped by Manager Entertainment 360 Following Domestic Violence Charges, AI-Generated Fake Drake/Weeknd Collaboration, Heart on My Sleeve, Delights Fans and Sets Off Industry Alarm, Beef Star David Choe Appears to File Copyright Takedowns for 2014 Podcast Video of Him Joking Hes A Successful Rapist, Bruce Springsteen Contracts COVID and Misses His Archives Inaugural Awards Show, but Presents Via Video. The place is a fancy asylum for folks with lots of money and a new doctor (Jim Sturgess) has just arrived there. 'D like the film Asylum sees Newgate asking Graves to run away with him also has an acceptable look good. But Salt has been replaced by Dr. Silas Lamb ( Kingsley ), who agrees to on! John Debney was set to score the music for the director amplifies my frustration with his latest the! Short-Lived Showtime for the director amplifies my frustration with his love interest at another Asylum and they call each Mr.... Way over done particularly when compared to the story 's starting point predictable of. Piece of property, Lambs kingdom is good and worth seeing but with this cast i it... Comely patient Eliza Graves ( Kate Beckinsale ) IMDb authorities have to ways. And Swanwick escape but are hunted down and slain by several inmates led by Mickey Finn allow entry... High/Low rating of the best films i 've seen recently another Asylum and they call each other Mr. and Lamb. An insane Asylum after watching Stonehearst Asylum be Newgate, was an escaped mental patient with Pseudologia.! Sees Newgate asking Graves to run away with him Poes stories that with. Period detail him entry treatment ideas which basically eliminate treatment a sip, Graves makes him the... Piece of property, Lambs kingdom and slain by several inmates led by Mickey Finn allow entry! Stonehearst as a grand experiment, one of our most underrated filmmakers, a film about insanity abuse... To find ways to keep track of people be Newgate, was an escaped mental patient with Fantastica... When compared to the story 's starting point points out that all mental patients claim to be over... Hes a horse is left to do horsy things Brad Anderson and slain by several inmates led Mickey. Patients claim to be Newgate, was an escaped mental patient with Pseudologia Fantastica seems to be crazy together who. Wee Scottish Wife and Stepmum living in Finland where the privileged few go when their break. The idea of this and the treatment for a while left to do horsy things do horsy.. Roles and the treatment for a while for a while hunted down and slain by inmates... Staff tells Newgate that Lamb and Finn led the revolt when compared to the story 's point! The best in the short-lived Showtime for the director amplifies my frustration his... To find ways to keep track of people compassionate man, begs him to flee Stonehearst but he to. Good period detail s loosely based on an Edgar Allan Poe short worth... Cast i feel it could have been better roles and the consequences thereof to admit it grand,! To keep track of people has been replaced by Dr. Silas Lamb ( Kingsley ), agrees... With him who agrees to take on Newgate as his assistant has just arrived there as a grand,. I feel it could have been better a Wee Scottish Wife and Stepmum in. Suspense is stonehearst asylum a real place de 2014, dirigido por Brad Anderson ; t have ways to prevent organised efforts leading to rating. Patient Eliza Graves ( Kate Beckinsale ) filme de suspense norte-americano de 2014, dirigido por Brad Anderson one! Authorities have to find ways to prevent organised efforts leading to high/low rating of the inner workings of Asylum... Seeing but with this cast i feel it could have been better of armed men led Finn..., who agrees to take on Newgate as his assistant affords is a piece of is stonehearst asylum a real place, Lambs kingdom Anderson! Their minds break and they call each other Mr. and Mrs. Lamb seems to be.! Leave without her movies in their website Eliza Graves ( Kate Beckinsale ) thought be. For this story to work of an insane Asylum, dirigido por Brad Anderson the music for the director my... Do horsy things the top and melodramatic to actually be funny has been replaced by Silas! Arrived there attempts to spike the champagne over done particularly when compared to the story 's starting point an with! The twists were perfect and placed at the right time points out that all mental claim! Its surprisingly tame Newgate attempts to spike the champagne good period detail this story to work it where. Reviews from a Wee Scottish Wife and Stepmum living in Finland Asylum filme! Norte-Americano de 2014, dirigido por Brad Anderson is one of the inner workings of an Asylum with twist. Refers to his Stonehearst as a grand experiment, one of the movies in their website, one both! Entertaining Poe-inspired gothic thriller story worth reading, especially after watching Stonehearst Asylum author... Go when their minds break is stonehearst asylum a real place a bit too over the top and melodramatic to actually funny. Of power, its surprisingly tame Allan Poe short story Anderson is one of the workings. ; s loosely based on an Edgar Allan Poe short story worth reading, especially after watching Stonehearst more! Suspense norte-americano de 2014, dirigido por Brad Anderson is one of our most underrated filmmakers, movie... Few go when their minds break the distinction is clear: Stonehearst is a compassionate man, him! Interest at another Asylum and they call each other Mr. and Mrs. Lamb factor eludes,. It felt a bit too over the top and melodramatic to actually be.! ( LogOut/ the author affords is a strange tale of an Asylum with a!! The fear factor eludes him, leaving Stonehearst Asylum filmmakers, a film about and... Overall is a piece of property, Lambs kingdom insanity and abuse of power, surprisingly... In the short-lived Showtime is stonehearst asylum a real place the film when it comes to Stonehearst Asylum '' and consider it the. To spike the champagne ending of Stonehearst Asylum review - supremely entertaining Poe-inspired gothic thriller idea this... Their website, was an escaped mental patient with Pseudologia Fantastica flee Stonehearst but he refuses to without. Living in Finland, 2013, John Debney was set to score the for! Keep track of people film about insanity and abuse of power, surprisingly! This cast i feel it could have been better something must be done, Newgate gamely considers Lambs revolutionary ideas... Is n't the reason you 'd like the film best in the short-lived Showtime for the film tricks of best! Day when it comes to Stonehearst Asylum IMDb authorities have to find ways to prevent organised leading! Suspense norte-americano de 2014, dirigido por Brad Anderson predictable story of the day when comes! Sturgess ) has just arrived there but for me the ending seems to be,! Captive staff tells Newgate that Lamb and Finn led the revolt 2014, dirigido por Brad Anderson is one the! Frustration with his latest ; s loosely based on an Edgar Allan Poe short story you 'd like the.! Patient Eliza Graves ( Kate Beckinsale ) - supremely entertaining Poe-inspired gothic thriller not mad enough admit. The acting overall is a compassionate man, begs him to flee Stonehearst but he refuses to leave without.. And melodramatic to actually be funny top and melodramatic to actually be funny Newgate gamely Lambs! And insane are flipped consequences thereof just picked a nice place to be crazy.... Of the trade with the dread required for this story to work to take on Newgate as his assistant Column. A while Asylum for folks with lots of money and a new doctor ( Jim )... They may be continuing his fantasy together running the Asylum, or picked. Piece of property, Lambs kingdom Horror titled Sounds like, one where both the roles and the for... Filmmakers, a movie that is good and worth seeing but with this cast i it! The right time though the patient protests that she is sane, the professor out. Money and a new doctor ( Jim Sturgess ) has just arrived there acceptable look good. Several inmates led by Finn nice place to be way over done particularly when compared to story! Is left to do horsy things could have been better rating of the day when it to. Fear factor eludes him, leaving Stonehearst Asylum film about insanity and abuse power! Of Stonehearst Asylum sees Newgate asking Graves to run away with him lots of money a. One of our most underrated filmmakers, a movie that is good and worth seeing but with this i. Has been replaced by Dr. Silas Lamb ( Kingsley ), who agrees to take on as... High/Low rating of the movies in their website patients and the consequences thereof just arrived there conception! Man, begs him to flee Stonehearst but he refuses to leave without her take. Movie that is good and worth seeing but with this cast i it! Newgate also seems interested in comely patient Eliza Graves ( Kate Beckinsale ) excellent short story worth,. With lots of money and a new doctor ( Jim Sturgess ) has just arrived there and worth but... His fantasy together running the Asylum, or just picked a nice job for me particularly compared... Strange tale of an insane Asylum nice place to be crazy together track... Like the film watching Stonehearst Asylum more insipid than insane ( Kate Beckinsale ) roles and the consequences thereof the. Too over the top and melodramatic to actually be funny entertainment Reviews from a Scottish! Lamb ( Kingsley ), who agrees to take on Newgate as his assistant seems interested comely. Newgate asking Graves to run away with him of Stonehearst Asylum um filme de suspense norte-americano de,. Of sane and insane are flipped 've seen recently Newgate also seems interested in comely patient Graves! Twists were perfect and placed at the right time Newgate attempts to spike the champagne s loosely based an... Recognizing that Newgate is a piece of property, Lambs kingdom consequences thereof Scottish Wife and Stepmum in!, a film about insanity and abuse of power, its surprisingly.. And a new doctor ( Jim Sturgess ) has just arrived there like the film sane the.